Asking someone to do work on Spec means that they put all the time and energy into the work without any guarantee that they would ever receive any compensation for the work. We are nineteen05 are whole hearted against SPEC work. So why is it wrong?
The reason it has been an issue for designers in particular is that after a designer has finished their work, the client would reject it not liking something and the designer is then out of their time/effort/money. While the concept of spec work does exist on large scale (competitions for major building designs). Unless you are holding a competition for your new church building, don’t do spec work. Even with volunteers.
The newly appointed president of AIGA (the international designers association), Debbie Millman, on Spec Work.
I am personally vigorously, passionately and fundamentally AGAINST designers being asked to do work on spec and neither I nor my firm will ever participate in speculative work. I have said it before and I will say it again: Speculative work denigrates both the agencies and the designers that participate. If we give away our work for free, if we give away our talent and our expertise, we give away more than the work. We give away our souls.
Read the full interview over at NO!SPEC.
For more information on the NO!SPEC movement.
In another article about the Debbie Millman, the author referenced these great articles. The top three are particularly helpful for how the church is most likely to cross the SPEC boundary line.
Hat Nod: swissmiss